Player Radar 2019 | Dylan Roberton

After an unfortunate and scary heart scare in his fourth and final game of season 2018, Dylan Roberton comes in to this season at what looks to be a bargain price tag. Let’s take a look at the St Kilda defender.

Player: Dylan Roberton
Team: St. Kilda
Age: 27
Price: $297,500
Position: Defender
Games played 2018: 4
2018 average: 68
100+ scores: 0
90+ scores: 1


Firstly, Dylan Roberton started the season at $509,000 in 2018 which makes him look like an absolute steal. This year he’s priced $212,000 cheaper and is supposedly over the heart issues that hampered his season last year.

He has publicly said “no worry from my end” and “as far as my mental state, I’m ready to go,” when asked by reporters on his body. Those comments will put coaches’ minds at ease.

Roberton completed his first competitive hit out in the Saints intra-club game a couple of weeks ago and managed to play eye-catching footy. Roberton had 19 kicks and six intercept marks playing as a floater, third tall-type defender.

Form like this is encouraging considering his past averages and capabilities having twice managing to average 90 points per game over a season. That’s a history that not many of the options under $300k can boast.

[interaction id=”5c7670a72dcf2a4106e016e4″]

As well as performing well in the intra-club match, Roberton managed to star in his JLT game against North Melbourne on the weekend.

After starting slowly in the first half playing as key position player, Robbo was able to have an impressive second half which resulted in him scoring 103 points for the game.

JLT Series notebook: See what all the relevant players have done

An example of Robbo’s price and how the cash can be used elsewhere can be displayed through popular selection Alex Witherden, who is price $158k more than Robbo.

Witherden is in 15% of sides and has been touted as a breakout contender. However, if we’re being realistic, both he and Roberton are not likely to finish the year as top six defenders.

In this scenario, Roberton would make more money as a ‘value’ selection compared to Witherden and potentially at a similar scoring output. That extra cash could then be used to upgrade elsewhere, like turning Goldstein into Gawn. Something to think about.


The one big negative that stands out in the selection of Roberton is his unknown role. With Jake Carlisle going down, many footy fans believe Robbo will play key position.

Who will breakout in 2019? See Matty’s Top 20 Contenders

In his JLT game on the weekend key position was the role he played throughout the first half. Robbo’s SuperCoach impact was limited and he was barely touching the footy. It’s probably the only con I can see for Roberton but it’s quite a significant one if the cards fall the wrong way for SuperCoach players.


If he doesn’t play key position at $297k he is an absolute lock based on his pre-season form. It’s just that uncertainty that has a little bit of doubt creeping in to my mind. At the moment he is in my side.

Check to see Saints’ round one side. If it has two key position players and Roberton then pick him. If not, then he’s probably not the best pick around.

18 days to go: Tim Kelly Player Radar

19 days to go: Toby Nankervis Player Radar

20 days to go: Detailed JLT Series notes

21 days to go: Tim Taranto Player Radar

22 days to go: Matty’s Top 20 Breakout Contenders

23 days to go: Shorty’s Worst Ever Trade

24 days to go: Fresh Faces | Freo, Geel, GC, GWS

25 days to go: Anthony Miles Player Profile

26 days to go: The Praccy Matches – and what they mean for SuperCoach 

27 days to go: Brodie Smith Player Radar

28 days to go: Kade Simpson Player Radar

29 days to go: The Premiums | Midfielders

30 days to go: Callum Mills Player Profile

31 days to go: Adam Cerra Player Radar

32 days to go: Lachie Neale Player Radar

33 days to go: Fresh Faces | Adel, Bris, Carl, Coll, Ess

34 days to go: Matty’s Top 50 Rookies & Mature-Aged Players

35 days to go: The Premiums | Defenders

36 days to go: The Floating Donut Explained

37 days to go: The Burn List – Michael Walters

38 days to go: Todd Goldstein Player Radar

39 days to go: How the new rules will impact SuperCoach

40 days to go: SuperCoach positional analysis

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.